This PR points out that we are rejecting valid code in C++20. The problem is that we were surreptitiously transforming T& t(e) into T& t{e} which is wrong, because the type of e had a conversion function to T, while aggregate initialization of t from e doesn't work. Therefore, I was violating a design principle of P0960, which says that any existing meaning of A(b) should not change. So I think we should only attempt to aggregate-initialize if the original expression was ill-formed. Another design principle is that () should work where {} works, so this: struct S { int i; }; const S& s(1); has to keep working. Thus the special handling for paren-lists with one element. (A paren-list with more than one element would give you "error: expression list treated as compound expression in initializer" C++17.) PR c++/93790 * call.c (initialize_reference): If the reference binding failed, maybe try initializing from { }. * decl.c (grok_reference_init): For T& t(e), set LOOKUP_AGGREGATE_PAREN_INIT but don't build up a constructor yet. * g++.dg/cpp2a/paren-init23.C: New test. * g++.dg/init/aggr14.C: New test.
Name |
Last commit
|
Last update |
---|---|---|
INSTALL | Loading commit data... | |
config | Loading commit data... | |
contrib | Loading commit data... | |
fixincludes | Loading commit data... | |
gcc | Loading commit data... | |
gnattools | Loading commit data... | |
gotools | Loading commit data... | |
include | Loading commit data... | |
intl | Loading commit data... | |
libada | Loading commit data... | |
libatomic | Loading commit data... | |
libbacktrace | Loading commit data... | |
libcc1 | Loading commit data... | |
libcpp | Loading commit data... | |
libdecnumber | Loading commit data... | |
libffi | Loading commit data... | |
libgcc | Loading commit data... | |
libgfortran | Loading commit data... | |
libgo | Loading commit data... | |
libgomp | Loading commit data... | |
libhsail-rt | Loading commit data... | |
libiberty | Loading commit data... | |
libitm | Loading commit data... | |
libobjc | Loading commit data... | |
liboffloadmic | Loading commit data... | |
libphobos | Loading commit data... | |
libquadmath | Loading commit data... | |
libsanitizer | Loading commit data... | |
libssp | Loading commit data... | |
libstdc++-v3 | Loading commit data... | |
libvtv | Loading commit data... | |
lto-plugin | Loading commit data... | |
maintainer-scripts | Loading commit data... | |
zlib | Loading commit data... | |
.dir-locals.el | Loading commit data... | |
.gitattributes | Loading commit data... | |
.gitignore | Loading commit data... | |
ABOUT-NLS | Loading commit data... | |
COPYING | Loading commit data... | |
COPYING.LIB | Loading commit data... | |
COPYING.RUNTIME | Loading commit data... | |
COPYING3 | Loading commit data... | |
COPYING3.LIB | Loading commit data... | |
ChangeLog | Loading commit data... | |
ChangeLog.jit | Loading commit data... | |
ChangeLog.tree-ssa | Loading commit data... | |
MAINTAINERS | Loading commit data... | |
Makefile.def | Loading commit data... | |
Makefile.in | Loading commit data... | |
Makefile.tpl | Loading commit data... | |
README | Loading commit data... | |
ar-lib | Loading commit data... | |
compile | Loading commit data... | |
config-ml.in | Loading commit data... | |
config.guess | Loading commit data... | |
config.rpath | Loading commit data... | |
config.sub | Loading commit data... | |
configure | Loading commit data... | |
configure.ac | Loading commit data... | |
depcomp | Loading commit data... | |
install-sh | Loading commit data... | |
libtool-ldflags | Loading commit data... | |
libtool.m4 | Loading commit data... | |
ltgcc.m4 | Loading commit data... | |
ltmain.sh | Loading commit data... | |
ltoptions.m4 | Loading commit data... | |
ltsugar.m4 | Loading commit data... | |
ltversion.m4 | Loading commit data... | |
lt~obsolete.m4 | Loading commit data... | |
missing | Loading commit data... | |
mkdep | Loading commit data... | |
mkinstalldirs | Loading commit data... | |
move-if-change | Loading commit data... | |
multilib.am | Loading commit data... | |
symlink-tree | Loading commit data... | |
test-driver | Loading commit data... | |
ylwrap | Loading commit data... |