Skip to content
Projects
Groups
Snippets
Help
This project
Loading...
Sign in / Register
Toggle navigation
A
abc
Overview
Overview
Details
Activity
Cycle Analytics
Repository
Repository
Files
Commits
Branches
Tags
Contributors
Graph
Compare
Charts
Issues
0
Issues
0
List
Board
Labels
Milestones
Merge Requests
0
Merge Requests
0
CI / CD
CI / CD
Pipelines
Jobs
Schedules
Charts
Wiki
Wiki
Snippets
Snippets
Members
Members
Collapse sidebar
Close sidebar
Activity
Graph
Charts
Create a new issue
Jobs
Commits
Issue Boards
Open sidebar
lvzhengyang
abc
Commits
59d7455c
Commit
59d7455c
authored
Feb 03, 2011
by
Alan Mishchenko
Browse files
Options
Browse Files
Download
Email Patches
Plain Diff
Minor changes while improving BDD-based reachability.
parent
1d54983b
Hide whitespace changes
Inline
Side-by-side
Showing
3 changed files
with
84 additions
and
48 deletions
+84
-48
src/aig/llb/llb3Image.c
+1
-1
src/aig/llb/llb3Nonlin.c
+81
-44
src/bdd/cudd/cuddAndAbs.c
+2
-3
No files found.
src/aig/llb/llb3Image.c
View file @
59d7455c
...
@@ -355,7 +355,7 @@ Llb_NonlinPrint( p );
...
@@ -355,7 +355,7 @@ Llb_NonlinPrint( p );
printf
(
"Conjoining partitions %d and %d.
\n
"
,
pPart1
->
iPart
,
pPart2
->
iPart
);
printf
(
"Conjoining partitions %d and %d.
\n
"
,
pPart1
->
iPart
,
pPart2
->
iPart
);
Extra_bddPrintSupport
(
p
->
dd
,
bCube
);
printf
(
"
\n
"
);
Extra_bddPrintSupport
(
p
->
dd
,
bCube
);
printf
(
"
\n
"
);
}
}
// derive new function
// derive new function
// bFunc = Cudd_bddAndAbstract( p->dd, pPart1->bFunc, pPart2->bFunc, bCube ); Cudd_Ref( bFunc );
// bFunc = Cudd_bddAndAbstract( p->dd, pPart1->bFunc, pPart2->bFunc, bCube ); Cudd_Ref( bFunc );
bFunc
=
Cudd_bddAndAbstractLimit
(
p
->
dd
,
pPart1
->
bFunc
,
pPart2
->
bFunc
,
bCube
,
Limit
);
bFunc
=
Cudd_bddAndAbstractLimit
(
p
->
dd
,
pPart1
->
bFunc
,
pPart2
->
bFunc
,
bCube
,
Limit
);
...
...
src/aig/llb/llb3Nonlin.c
View file @
59d7455c
...
@@ -21,7 +21,7 @@
...
@@ -21,7 +21,7 @@
#include "llbInt.h"
#include "llbInt.h"
ABC_NAMESPACE_IMPL_START
ABC_NAMESPACE_IMPL_START
////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
/// DECLARATIONS ///
/// DECLARATIONS ///
...
@@ -82,7 +82,7 @@ int Llb_NonlinFindBestVar( DdManager * dd, DdNode * bFunc, Aig_Man_t * pAig )
...
@@ -82,7 +82,7 @@ int Llb_NonlinFindBestVar( DdManager * dd, DdNode * bFunc, Aig_Man_t * pAig )
{
{
int
fVerbose
=
0
;
int
fVerbose
=
0
;
Aig_Obj_t
*
pObj
;
Aig_Obj_t
*
pObj
;
DdNode
*
bCof
,
*
bVar
,
*
bTemp
;
DdNode
*
bCof
,
*
bVar
;
int
i
,
iVar
,
iVarBest
=
-
1
,
iValue
,
iValueBest
=
ABC_INFINITY
,
Size0Best
=
-
1
;
int
i
,
iVar
,
iVarBest
=
-
1
,
iValue
,
iValueBest
=
ABC_INFINITY
,
Size0Best
=
-
1
;
int
Size
,
Size0
,
Size1
;
int
Size
,
Size0
,
Size1
;
int
clk
=
clock
();
int
clk
=
clock
();
...
@@ -93,46 +93,42 @@ int Llb_NonlinFindBestVar( DdManager * dd, DdNode * bFunc, Aig_Man_t * pAig )
...
@@ -93,46 +93,42 @@ int Llb_NonlinFindBestVar( DdManager * dd, DdNode * bFunc, Aig_Man_t * pAig )
{
{
iVar
=
Aig_ObjId
(
pObj
);
iVar
=
Aig_ObjId
(
pObj
);
if
(
fVerbose
)
if
(
fVerbose
)
printf
(
"Var =%3d : "
,
iVar
);
printf
(
"Var =%3d : "
,
iVar
);
bVar
=
Cudd_bddIthVar
(
dd
,
iVar
);
bVar
=
Cudd_bddIthVar
(
dd
,
iVar
);
bCof
=
Cudd_Cofactor
(
dd
,
bFunc
,
Cudd_Not
(
bVar
)
);
Cudd_Ref
(
bCof
);
bCof
=
Cudd_bddAnd
(
dd
,
bFunc
,
Cudd_Not
(
bVar
)
);
Cudd_Ref
(
bCof
);
bCof
=
Cudd_bddAnd
(
dd
,
bTemp
=
bCof
,
Cudd_Not
(
bVar
)
);
Cudd_Ref
(
bCof
);
Cudd_RecursiveDeref
(
dd
,
bTemp
);
Size0
=
Cudd_DagSize
(
bCof
);
Size0
=
Cudd_DagSize
(
bCof
);
if
(
fVerbose
)
if
(
fVerbose
)
printf
(
"Supp0 =%3d "
,
Cudd_SupportSize
(
dd
,
bCof
)
);
printf
(
"Supp0 =%3d "
,
Cudd_SupportSize
(
dd
,
bCof
)
);
if
(
fVerbose
)
if
(
fVerbose
)
printf
(
"Size0 =%6d "
,
Size0
);
printf
(
"Size0 =%6d "
,
Size0
);
Cudd_RecursiveDeref
(
dd
,
bCof
);
Cudd_RecursiveDeref
(
dd
,
bCof
);
bCof
=
Cudd_Cofactor
(
dd
,
bFunc
,
bVar
);
Cudd_Ref
(
bCof
);
bCof
=
Cudd_bddAnd
(
dd
,
bFunc
,
bVar
);
Cudd_Ref
(
bCof
);
bCof
=
Cudd_bddAnd
(
dd
,
bTemp
=
bCof
,
bVar
);
Cudd_Ref
(
bCof
);
Cudd_RecursiveDeref
(
dd
,
bTemp
);
Size1
=
Cudd_DagSize
(
bCof
);
Size1
=
Cudd_DagSize
(
bCof
);
if
(
fVerbose
)
if
(
fVerbose
)
printf
(
"Supp1 =%3d "
,
Cudd_SupportSize
(
dd
,
bCof
)
);
printf
(
"Supp1 =%3d "
,
Cudd_SupportSize
(
dd
,
bCof
)
);
if
(
fVerbose
)
if
(
fVerbose
)
printf
(
"Size1 =%6d "
,
Size1
);
printf
(
"Size1 =%6d "
,
Size1
);
Cudd_RecursiveDeref
(
dd
,
bCof
);
Cudd_RecursiveDeref
(
dd
,
bCof
);
iValue
=
ABC_MAX
(
Size0
,
Size1
)
-
ABC_MIN
(
Size0
,
Size1
)
+
Size0
+
Size1
-
Size
;
iValue
=
ABC_MAX
(
Size0
,
Size1
)
-
ABC_MIN
(
Size0
,
Size1
)
+
Size0
+
Size1
-
Size
;
if
(
fVerbose
)
if
(
fVerbose
)
printf
(
"D =%6d "
,
Size0
+
Size1
-
Size
);
printf
(
"D =%6d "
,
Size0
+
Size1
-
Size
);
if
(
fVerbose
)
if
(
fVerbose
)
printf
(
"B =%6d "
,
ABC_MAX
(
Size0
,
Size1
)
-
ABC_MIN
(
Size0
,
Size1
)
);
printf
(
"B =%6d "
,
ABC_MAX
(
Size0
,
Size1
)
-
ABC_MIN
(
Size0
,
Size1
)
);
if
(
fVerbose
)
if
(
fVerbose
)
printf
(
"S =%6d
\n
"
,
iValue
);
printf
(
"S =%6d
\n
"
,
iValue
);
if
(
Size0
>
1
&&
Size1
>
1
&&
iValueBest
>
iValue
)
if
(
iValueBest
>
iValue
)
{
{
iValueBest
=
iValue
;
iValueBest
=
iValue
;
iVarBest
=
i
Var
;
iVarBest
=
i
;
Size0Best
=
Size0
;
Size0Best
=
Size0
;
}
}
}
}
printf
(
"BestVar = %4d. Value =%6d. Orig =%6d. Size0 =%6d. "
,
iVarBest
,
iValueBest
,
Size
,
Size0Best
);
printf
(
"BestVar = %4d/%4d. Value =%6d. Orig =%6d. Size0 =%6d. "
,
iVarBest
,
Aig_ObjId
(
Saig_ManLo
(
pAig
,
iVarBest
)),
iValueBest
,
Size
,
Size0Best
);
Abc_PrintTime
(
1
,
"Time"
,
clock
()
-
clk
);
Abc_PrintTime
(
1
,
"Time"
,
clock
()
-
clk
);
return
iVarBest
;
return
iVarBest
;
}
}
...
@@ -259,7 +255,14 @@ Abc_Cex_t * Llb_NonlinDeriveCex( Llb_Mnn_t * p )
...
@@ -259,7 +255,14 @@ Abc_Cex_t * Llb_NonlinDeriveCex( Llb_Mnn_t * p )
p
->
pVars2Q
[
Aig_ObjId
(
pObj
)]
=
1
;
p
->
pVars2Q
[
Aig_ObjId
(
pObj
)]
=
1
;
Vec_IntPush
(
vVarsNs
,
Aig_ObjId
(
pObj
)
);
Vec_IntPush
(
vVarsNs
,
Aig_ObjId
(
pObj
)
);
}
}
/*
Saig_ManForEachLo( p->pAig, pObj, i )
printf( "%d ", pObj->Id );
printf( "\n" );
Saig_ManForEachLi( p->pAig, pObj, i )
printf( "%d(%d) ", pObj->Id, Aig_ObjFaninId0(pObj) );
printf( "\n" );
*/
// allocate room for the counter-example
// allocate room for the counter-example
pCex
=
Ssw_SmlAllocCounterExample
(
Saig_ManRegNum
(
p
->
pAig
),
Saig_ManPiNum
(
p
->
pAig
),
Vec_PtrSize
(
p
->
vRings
)
);
pCex
=
Ssw_SmlAllocCounterExample
(
Saig_ManRegNum
(
p
->
pAig
),
Saig_ManPiNum
(
p
->
pAig
),
Vec_PtrSize
(
p
->
vRings
)
);
pCex
->
iFrame
=
Vec_PtrSize
(
p
->
vRings
)
-
1
;
pCex
->
iFrame
=
Vec_PtrSize
(
p
->
vRings
)
-
1
;
...
@@ -287,12 +290,14 @@ Abc_Cex_t * Llb_NonlinDeriveCex( Llb_Mnn_t * p )
...
@@ -287,12 +290,14 @@ Abc_Cex_t * Llb_NonlinDeriveCex( Llb_Mnn_t * p )
{
{
if
(
v
==
Vec_PtrSize
(
p
->
vRings
)
-
1
)
if
(
v
==
Vec_PtrSize
(
p
->
vRings
)
-
1
)
continue
;
continue
;
//Extra_bddPrintSupport( p->dd, bState ); printf( "\n" );
//Extra_bddPrintSupport( p->dd, bRing ); printf( "\n" );
// compute the next states
// compute the next states
bImage
=
Llb_NonlinImage
(
p
->
pAig
,
p
->
vLeaves
,
p
->
vRoots
,
p
->
pVars2Q
,
p
->
dd
,
bState
,
bImage
=
Llb_NonlinImage
(
p
->
pAig
,
p
->
vLeaves
,
p
->
vRoots
,
p
->
pVars2Q
,
p
->
dd
,
bState
,
p
->
pPars
->
fReorder
,
p
->
pPars
->
fVeryVerbose
,
p
->
pOrder
,
ABC_INFINITY
);
// consumed reference
p
->
pPars
->
fReorder
,
p
->
pPars
->
fVeryVerbose
,
p
->
pOrder
,
ABC_INFINITY
);
// consumed reference
assert
(
bImage
!=
NULL
);
assert
(
bImage
!=
NULL
);
Cudd_Ref
(
bImage
);
Cudd_Ref
(
bImage
);
//Extra_bddPrintSupport( p->dd, bImage ); printf( "\n" );
//Extra_bddPrintSupport( p->dd, bImage );
printf( "\n" );
// move reached states into ring manager
// move reached states into ring manager
bImage
=
Extra_TransferPermute
(
p
->
dd
,
p
->
ddR
,
bTemp
=
bImage
,
Vec_IntArray
(
p
->
vCs2Glo
)
);
Cudd_Ref
(
bImage
);
bImage
=
Extra_TransferPermute
(
p
->
dd
,
p
->
ddR
,
bTemp
=
bImage
,
Vec_IntArray
(
p
->
vCs2Glo
)
);
Cudd_Ref
(
bImage
);
...
@@ -349,7 +354,7 @@ Abc_Cex_t * Llb_NonlinDeriveCex( Llb_Mnn_t * p )
...
@@ -349,7 +354,7 @@ Abc_Cex_t * Llb_NonlinDeriveCex( Llb_Mnn_t * p )
int
Llb_NonlinReachability
(
Llb_Mnn_t
*
p
)
int
Llb_NonlinReachability
(
Llb_Mnn_t
*
p
)
{
{
DdNode
*
bCurrent
,
*
bNext
,
*
bTemp
;
DdNode
*
bCurrent
,
*
bNext
,
*
bTemp
;
int
nIters
,
nBddSize0
,
nBddSize
;
int
iVar
,
nIters
,
nBddSize0
,
nBddSize
,
Limit
=
p
->
pPars
->
nBddMax
;
int
clk2
,
clk3
,
clk
=
clock
();
int
clk2
,
clk3
,
clk
=
clock
();
assert
(
Aig_ManRegNum
(
p
->
pAig
)
>
0
);
assert
(
Aig_ManRegNum
(
p
->
pAig
)
>
0
);
...
@@ -400,37 +405,66 @@ int Llb_NonlinReachability( Llb_Mnn_t * p )
...
@@ -400,37 +405,66 @@ int Llb_NonlinReachability( Llb_Mnn_t * p )
return
0
;
return
0
;
}
}
// check the size
if
(
Cudd_DagSize
(
bCurrent
)
>
p
->
pPars
->
nBddMax
)
{
DdNode
*
bVar
,
*
bVarG
;
// find the best variable
iVar
=
Llb_NonlinFindBestVar
(
p
->
dd
,
bCurrent
,
p
->
pAig
);
// get cofactor in the working manager
bVar
=
Cudd_bddIthVar
(
p
->
dd
,
Aig_ObjId
(
Saig_ManLo
(
p
->
pAig
,
iVar
))
);
bCurrent
=
Cudd_bddAnd
(
p
->
dd
,
bTemp
=
bCurrent
,
Cudd_Not
(
bVar
)
);
Cudd_Ref
(
bCurrent
);
Cudd_RecursiveDeref
(
p
->
dd
,
bTemp
);
// get cofactor in the global manager
bVarG
=
Cudd_bddIthVar
(
p
->
ddG
,
iVar
);
p
->
ddG
->
bFunc2
=
Cudd_bddAnd
(
p
->
ddG
,
bTemp
=
p
->
ddG
->
bFunc2
,
Cudd_Not
(
bVarG
)
);
Cudd_Ref
(
p
->
ddG
->
bFunc2
);
Cudd_RecursiveDeref
(
p
->
ddG
,
bTemp
);
}
// compute the next states
// compute the next states
clk3
=
clock
();
clk3
=
clock
();
nBddSize0
=
Cudd_DagSize
(
bCurrent
);
nBddSize0
=
Cudd_DagSize
(
bCurrent
);
bNext
=
Llb_NonlinImage
(
p
->
pAig
,
p
->
vLeaves
,
p
->
vRoots
,
p
->
pVars2Q
,
p
->
dd
,
bCurrent
,
bNext
=
Llb_NonlinImage
(
p
->
pAig
,
p
->
vLeaves
,
p
->
vRoots
,
p
->
pVars2Q
,
p
->
dd
,
bCurrent
,
p
->
pPars
->
fReorder
,
p
->
pPars
->
fVeryVerbose
,
p
->
pOrder
,
p
->
pPars
->
nBddMax
);
// p->pPars->fReorder, p->pPars->fVeryVerbose, p->pOrder, nIters ? p->pPars->nBddMax : ABC_INFINITY );
p
->
pPars
->
fReorder
,
p
->
pPars
->
fVeryVerbose
,
p
->
pOrder
,
ABC_INFINITY
);
// Abc_PrintTime( 1, "Image time", clock() - clk3 );
if
(
bNext
==
NULL
)
// Llb_NonlimImage() consumes reference of bCurrent!!!
if
(
bNext
==
NULL
)
// Llb_NonlimImage() consumes reference of bCurrent!!!
{
{
int
iVar
;
DdNode
*
bVar
,
*
bVarG
;
DdNode
*
bVar
;
int
nDagSize
;
// if ( !p->pPars->fSilent )
// if ( !p->pPars->fSilent )
// printf( "Reached timeout during image computation (%d seconds).\n", p->pPars->TimeLimit );
// printf( "Reached timeout during image computation (%d seconds).\n", p->pPars->TimeLimit );
// p->pPars->iFrame = nIters - 1;
// p->pPars->iFrame = nIters - 1;
// return -1;
// return -1;
printf
(
"Should never happen!
\n
"
);
// get the frontier in the working manager
bCurrent
=
Extra_TransferPermute
(
p
->
ddG
,
p
->
dd
,
p
->
ddG
->
bFunc2
,
Vec_IntArray
(
p
->
vGlo2Cs
)
);
Cudd_Ref
(
bCurrent
);
bCurrent
=
Extra_TransferPermute
(
p
->
ddG
,
p
->
dd
,
p
->
ddG
->
bFunc2
,
Vec_IntArray
(
p
->
vGlo2Cs
)
);
Cudd_Ref
(
bCurrent
);
nDagSize
=
Cudd_DagSize
(
bCurrent
);
// find the best variable
iVar
=
Llb_NonlinFindBestVar
(
p
->
dd
,
bCurrent
,
p
->
pAig
);
iVar
=
Llb_NonlinFindBestVar
(
p
->
dd
,
bCurrent
,
p
->
pAig
);
bVar
=
Cudd_bddIthVar
(
p
->
dd
,
iVar
);
bCurrent
=
Cudd_Cofactor
(
p
->
dd
,
bTemp
=
bCurrent
,
Cudd_Not
(
bVar
)
);
Cudd_Ref
(
bCurrent
);
// get cofactor in the working manager
Cudd_RecursiveDeref
(
p
->
dd
,
bTemp
);
bVar
=
Cudd_bddIthVar
(
p
->
dd
,
Aig_ObjId
(
Saig_ManLo
(
p
->
pAig
,
iVar
))
);
bCurrent
=
Cudd_bddAnd
(
p
->
dd
,
bTemp
=
bCurrent
,
Cudd_Not
(
bVar
)
);
Cudd_Ref
(
bCurrent
);
bCurrent
=
Cudd_bddAnd
(
p
->
dd
,
bTemp
=
bCurrent
,
Cudd_Not
(
bVar
)
);
Cudd_Ref
(
bCurrent
);
Cudd_RecursiveDeref
(
p
->
dd
,
bTemp
);
Cudd_RecursiveDeref
(
p
->
dd
,
bTemp
);
// printf( "Before = %6d. After = %6d.\n", nDagSize, Cudd_DagSize(bCurrent) );
// get cofactor in the global manager
bVarG
=
Cudd_bddIthVar
(
p
->
dd
,
iVar
);
p
->
ddG
->
bFunc2
=
Cudd_bddAnd
(
p
->
ddG
,
bTemp
=
p
->
ddG
->
bFunc2
,
Cudd_Not
(
bVarG
)
);
Cudd_Ref
(
p
->
ddG
->
bFunc2
);
Cudd_RecursiveDeref
(
p
->
ddG
,
bTemp
);
p
->
pPars
->
nBddMax
=
3
*
p
->
pPars
->
nBddMax
/
2
;
// Cudd_ReduceHeap( p->dd, CUDD_REORDER_SIFT, 1 );
p
->
pPars
->
nBddMax
=
ABC_INFINITY
;
nIters
--
;
continue
;
continue
;
}
}
else
p
->
pPars
->
nBddMax
=
Limit
;
Cudd_Ref
(
bNext
);
Cudd_Ref
(
bNext
);
nBddSize
=
Cudd_DagSize
(
bNext
);
nBddSize
=
Cudd_DagSize
(
bNext
);
p
->
timeImage
+=
clock
()
-
clk3
;
p
->
timeImage
+=
clock
()
-
clk3
;
...
@@ -603,12 +637,15 @@ void Llb_MnnStop( Llb_Mnn_t * p )
...
@@ -603,12 +637,15 @@ void Llb_MnnStop( Llb_Mnn_t * p )
Vec_PtrForEachEntry
(
DdNode
*
,
p
->
vRings
,
bTemp
,
i
)
Vec_PtrForEachEntry
(
DdNode
*
,
p
->
vRings
,
bTemp
,
i
)
Cudd_RecursiveDeref
(
p
->
ddR
,
bTemp
);
Cudd_RecursiveDeref
(
p
->
ddR
,
bTemp
);
Vec_PtrFree
(
p
->
vRings
);
Vec_PtrFree
(
p
->
vRings
);
if
(
p
->
dd
R
->
bFunc
)
if
(
p
->
dd
G
->
bFunc
)
Cudd_RecursiveDeref
(
p
->
ddG
,
p
->
ddG
->
bFunc
);
Cudd_RecursiveDeref
(
p
->
ddG
,
p
->
ddG
->
bFunc
);
if
(
p
->
dd
R
->
bFunc2
)
if
(
p
->
dd
G
->
bFunc2
)
Cudd_RecursiveDeref
(
p
->
ddG
,
p
->
ddG
->
bFunc2
);
Cudd_RecursiveDeref
(
p
->
ddG
,
p
->
ddG
->
bFunc2
);
// printf( "manager1\n" );
Extra_StopManager
(
p
->
dd
);
Extra_StopManager
(
p
->
dd
);
// printf( "manager2\n" );
Extra_StopManager
(
p
->
ddG
);
Extra_StopManager
(
p
->
ddG
);
// printf( "manager3\n" );
Extra_StopManager
(
p
->
ddR
);
Extra_StopManager
(
p
->
ddR
);
Vec_IntFreeP
(
&
p
->
vCs2Glo
);
Vec_IntFreeP
(
&
p
->
vCs2Glo
);
Vec_IntFreeP
(
&
p
->
vNs2Glo
);
Vec_IntFreeP
(
&
p
->
vNs2Glo
);
...
...
src/bdd/cudd/cuddAndAbs.c
View file @
59d7455c
...
@@ -135,11 +135,10 @@ Cudd_bddAndAbstractLimit(
...
@@ -135,11 +135,10 @@ Cudd_bddAndAbstractLimit(
{
{
DdNode
*
res
;
DdNode
*
res
;
unsigned
int
saveLimit
=
manager
->
maxLive
;
unsigned
int
saveLimit
=
manager
->
maxLive
;
manager
->
maxLive
=
(
manager
->
keys
-
manager
->
dead
)
+
(
manager
->
keysZ
-
manager
->
deadZ
)
+
limit
;
do
{
do
{
manager
->
reordered
=
0
;
manager
->
reordered
=
0
;
manager
->
maxLive
=
(
manager
->
keys
-
manager
->
dead
)
+
(
manager
->
keysZ
-
manager
->
deadZ
)
+
limit
;
res
=
cuddBddAndAbstractRecur
(
manager
,
f
,
g
,
cube
);
res
=
cuddBddAndAbstractRecur
(
manager
,
f
,
g
,
cube
);
}
while
(
manager
->
reordered
==
1
);
}
while
(
manager
->
reordered
==
1
);
manager
->
maxLive
=
saveLimit
;
manager
->
maxLive
=
saveLimit
;
...
...
Write
Preview
Markdown
is supported
0%
Try again
or
attach a new file
Attach a file
Cancel
You are about to add
0
people
to the discussion. Proceed with caution.
Finish editing this message first!
Cancel
Please
register
or
sign in
to comment